On My Soap Box

Thanks to a spot on article in this week’s London Evening Standard I’ve joined a couple of protest groups.

For the many readers who live outside London, you might not be familiar with the area known as Portobello. The largest open air antiques market in the world, for the sartorially inclined it is a treasure-trove of second-hand fountains pens, cuff links, tie bars, watches and vintage clothing. The street market that stretches from Ladbroke Grove to Notting Hill is a cornucopia of sights, sounds and smells. Portobello provides not only the above but freshly prepared foods from the mundane to the exotic. It’s also home to some great independent retailers, Adam of London being my favourite.

Sadly this is all under threat. Recently an AllSaints store opened on the street, and in order to accommodate its 15,000sqft – the length of seven shop fronts – over 150 independent antique dealers were evicted from what was formally Lipka’s Antiques Arcade. You may think; how is one store a threat?

What retailers see is footfall. What they fail to understand is that the reason people like me go there is precisely because they’re not there. The arrival of this soulless dross palace will give heart to all the other rapacious chain retailers, landlords and property speculators who see this wonderful area as underdeveloped and ripe for exploitation.

What is happening in Portobello is happening in many of London’s unique retail areas – a sort of retail equivalent of acne. Bates Hats and Barons of Piccadilly, a favourite independent gents retailer of mine and fellow columnist Winston Chesterfield, are both victims of redevelopment of buildings on Jermyn Street. While Bates has secured space in Hilditch & Key it won’t be the same. Sadly Barons is going out of business all together. And as good as TM Lewin, Charles Tyrwhitt and Hawes & Curtis are at supplying cheap shirting, they’re not shirt makers as Cary Grant or the Duke of Windsor would have recognised them. How long before Jermyn Street is just any other?

If you saw the BBC’s four part series on Savile Row you’ll have seen the tailors work rooms being moved from top floors into basements to make room for hedge fund managers; and the arrival of Abercrombie & Fitch on the Row indicative of commercial interests coming before character, variety and quality.

It is often said of the English that we are incapable of appreciating what we have.


  1. Sirian said:

    Couldn’t agree more with you. Pedestrian stores like “All Saints” should never have been allowed to surface in an ideal world. I too wish that Saville Row did not sport so much of the shops that are “Argos” of shirts like Hawes & Curtis too.

    March 11, 2010
  2. Michael said:

    Andrew, this is disgusting.A thriving community like Portobello must not be allowed to be destroyed by the rapacious types and replaced by mindless AllSaints stores and sterile latte strips. Cities such as Berlin, Copenhagen and Paris amongst others, know the value these thriving communities and what they contribute to their cities, commercially and culturally.And its a contribution over the very long term.
    I would suggest you contact Tyler Brule at Monocle, who is a passionate advocate of this issue to assist in this very worthwhile campaign.

    March 11, 2010
  3. Andrew said:

    That’s a very good idea, thank you Michael. And I agree with you, the French are much smarter about this sort of thing.

    March 12, 2010
  4. Our High Streets increasingly resemble motorway service stations without the cars. We must fight for what we have for when it is gone, it is gone. Much could be done if our politicians really cared. Lower business rates for boutiques and one-off stores. Reviving the Roman practice that all master craftsmen must employ an apprentice by law but waive the employers national insurance contributions. Small can be beautiful.

    March 16, 2010

Comments are closed.